Accident Reconstruction Newsletter is brought to you by the ARC Network, your resource for accident reconstruction and traffic accident investigation.
Return to ARC Network

accident reconstruction newsletter
Volume Six, Issue 4
Upcoming Crash Conferences
accident reconstruction network
SUBMIT AN ARTICLE
If you would like to submit an article to the Accident Reconstruction Newsletter, please email the ARC Network:
arc@accidentreconstruction.com

RETURN TO APRIL 2004 NEWSLETTER

Estimating Crash Severity: Can Event Data Recorders Replace Crash Reconstruction?

The primary description of crash severity in most crash databases is vehicle delta-V. Delta-V has been traditionally estimated through crash reconstruction techniques using computer codes, e.g. Crash3 and WinSmash. Unfortunately, delta-V is notoriously difficult to estimate in many types of collisions including sideswipes, collisions with narrow objects, angled side impacts, and rollovers. Indeed, approximately 50% of all delta-V estimates in the National Automotive Sampling System / Crashworthiness Data System (NASS/CDS) 2000 are reported as unknown.

The Event Data Recorders (EDRs), now being installed as standard equipment by several automakers, have the potential to provide an independent measurement of crash severity, which avoids many of the difficulties of crash reconstruction techniques. This paper evaluates the feasibility of replacing delta-V estimates from crash reconstruction with the delta-V computed from EDRs. The analysis is based on 225 NASS/CDS cases from 1999 - 2001, which have corresponding EDR datasets. The potential of extracting manual seat belt use from EDRs is also discussed and compared with the corresponding results from NASS/CDS gathered by crash investigators. Although EDRs are expected to greatly enhance the investigation of a crash, it should be noted however that current EDRs are not perfect. The paper discusses the limitations of current EDR technology and the need for enhancement of future Event Data Recorders.

Download the complete paper (PDF)

RETURN TO APRIL 2004 NEWSLETTER

Please direct any questions regarding this issue of the Accident Reconstruction Newsletter to the ARC Network

© 2004 ARC Network, LLC. All rights reserved. Any comments, questions or suggestions should be e-mailed to the ARC Network.

ARC NETWORK QUICK LINKS
Homepage
| Contact Us | Guest Book | Advertising
AR News | Book Store | Corporate Directory | Discussion Forum | Education | Events Calendar | Expert Witness Directory | Membership
Newsletter | Organizations | Police Department Directory | Research Directory